The patient presented upon referral from Dr. S to retrieve a fractured abutment fragment from a Straumann 4.8 bone level implant in the #3 site. The case had been restored for approximately 2 years when the fracture occurred. The abutment was a TiBase design, of unidentified origin, with the fracture occurring at the base of the external titanium cylinder. Unfortunately, this type of fracture is not uncommon as it is in a stress riser zone at the weakest cross section in the pillar where the torsional loading from the molar restoration can deliver the most force. Following a preclinical explanation of the recovery protocol, the abutment fragment was “wobbled” loose with a custom throughbore tool. The implant was cleaned and in the absence of a titanium healing abutment a provisional silicone plug was placed to help control the tissue profile. The patient was advised to have a custom titanium abutment placed which would have a significantly thicker titanium cross section in the critical fracture area.